Skip to main content
Peer-Reviewed Open Access · CC BY-NC 4.0

Editorial Policies / Peer Review Recognition

Policy 15 of 15

Peer Review Recognition NFSU

How reviewers earn formal, verifiable credit for their work through the Web of Science Reviewer Recognition Service (formerly Publons), without compromising confidentiality.

Publisher: (National Forensic Sciences University) National Forensic Sciences University Effective: July 2026 Version: v1

[15]

Peer-Review Recognition

Peer Review is unpaid, largely invisible work that the whole system depends on. NFSU gives reviewers formal, verifiable recognition for it through the Web of Science Reviewer Recognition Service (formerly Publons), while protecting the confidentiality of every review.

Web of Science Reviewer Recognition (formerly Publons)

Publons merged into Web of Science in 2022; reviewer recognition is now provided by the Web of Science Reviewer Recognition Service. Reviewers for NFSU can opt in to have their completed reviews added, in verified form, to their Web of Science Researcher Profile — building a citable record of their reviewing for use in promotion, tenure and funding applications. Recognition applies even when the review is anonymous and even if the manuscript is never published.

What is recorded — and what stays private

Recognition never breaks confidentiality. By default, a reviewer's profile shows only the journal title and the number and year of reviews; the content of the review remains confidential and the review model's anonymity is preserved. Review content is only ever displayed where the journal operates transparent Peer Review and the reviewer consents.

Confidentiality first

Recognition records the fact of a review, not its content. Under our default double-anonymised model, author and reviewer identities are never exposed through the recognition service.

How reviewers opt in

  1. 1

    Choose recognition when you review

    A prompt during review in the submission system lets you send the completed review to your Web of Science profile.

  2. 2

    Create or connect your profile

    If you don't have a Web of Science Researcher Profile, you're guided to create one (free); if you do, the review is added and verified.

  3. 3

    Automate future reviews

    You can set future reviews for the journal to be added automatically, or add them one at a time.

ORCID integration

Verified review activity can also be reflected on your ORCID record, so your reviewing appears alongside your publications in the identifier researchers and funders already use. Author and reviewer ORCID use is set out in our submission and peer-review policies.

Other forms of recognition

  • Reviewer certificates on request, confirming reviews completed for the journal.
  • Annual acknowledgement of the journal's reviewers (with consent).
  • Editor recognition — handling-editor work can likewise be recorded on a Web of Science Researcher Profile.

Recognition and review integrity

Recognition is offered to value genuine, good-faith reviewing. It is never contingent on recommending a particular decision, and reviewing to inflate a recognition record, or any manipulation of the review process, is treated under the Publication Ethics policy.

Standards & verification

Aligned with COPE recognition-of-reviewers guidance and ICMJE. Integration availability depends on the submission platform; confirm the current Web of Science Reviewer Recognition partnership and setup with the editorial office. See also the Peer Review Policy.

An unhandled error has occurred. Reload 🗙