Editorial Policies / Standards, Indexing & Q1/Q2 Readiness
Transparency · Indexing · Ranking Readiness
Standards, Indexing & Q1/Q2 Readiness NFSU
One auditable view: every policy mapped to the international standard it meets, plus readiness against the databases that matter — Scopus, Web of Science, PubMed/PMC, DOAJ, Crossref and Publons — and an honest guide to what quartile ranking actually requires.
How Q1 / Q2 really works
Quartiles are not set by policy. They come from citation metrics — Scopus CiteScore quartiles and Web of Science Journal Citation Reports (JIF) quartiles — calculated within a subject category over several years. A journal must first be indexed in Scopus or WoS, then accumulate citations, before any quartile exists. A complete standards-grade policy framework is the entry requirement for indexing and the foundation that helps earn citations; it cannot by itself produce a Q1/Q2 rank.
Indexing & database readiness
| Database | Core requirement | Status |
|---|---|---|
| DOAJ | OA statement, CC licence, author-retained copyright, peer-review & ethics policies, editorial board, APC transparency, ISSN | Policy in place |
| Crossref | DOI registration + rich XML metadata deposit | Operational |
| Google Scholar | Highwire citation meta tags, HTML+PDF full text, stable URLs | Policy in place |
| OpenAlex | Harvests Crossref / open metadata | Met via Crossref |
| Scopus (CSAB) | Peer-review policy, COPE ethics, editorial board with affiliations, ISSN, on-time publication, DOIs, content quality & citedness | Policy in place |
| Web of Science (Clarivate) | Editorial rigour, Peer Review, ethics, board diversity, timeliness; ESCI first, then SCIE/SSCI/AHCI on impact | Policy in place |
| PubMed Central / MEDLINE | Scientific + editorial quality; JATS XML full text; ethics, consent, trial registration | Policy in place |
| Publons / WoS Reviewer Recognition | Reviewer recognition integration & verified review records | Policy in place |
| ORCID | Authenticated iDs for authors (and reviewers) | Policy in place |
Scopus & Web of Science selection criteria — mapped
Both databases evaluate journals against broadly similar quality signals. Typical criteria and where each is addressed:
| Selection criterion | Where addressed | Status |
|---|---|---|
| Convincing editorial concept / clear Aims & Scope | Aims & Scope page | Policy in place |
| Peer Review policy, clearly described | Peer Review Policy | Policy in place |
| Publication ethics & malpractice statement (COPE) | Publication Ethics + ethics set | Policy in place |
| Editorial board — identifiable, with affiliations & diversity | Editorial Board page | Policy in place |
| Regular, on-time publication + stated frequency | Publication Frequency page | Policy in place |
| ISSN, English titles & abstracts, references in Roman script | Author Guidelines + metadata | Policy in place |
| DOIs & quality metadata | Metadata Policy | Operational |
| Content relevance, originality & academic contribution | Editorial + Peer Review standards | Policy in place |
| Citedness of articles / journal impact | Citation performance over time | Performance-based |
| International diversity of authors, reviewers & board | Governance + outreach | Performance-based |
Verify current criteria
Selection guidance is updated periodically. Confirm against the official sources before applying: Scopus content policy, Web of Science editorial selection process, PMC/MEDLINE, ICMJE and DOAJ.
Full policy suite
The complete set a top-tier, internationally indexed journal is expected to publish:
Author policies
Reviewer policies
Editorial policies
Journal / publisher policies
Legal policies
Path to indexing
Publish consistently on schedule, then apply to DOAJ first, followed by Scopus and Web of Science (ESCI). Quartile standing follows once citations accrue.
Frameworks & bodies referenced
Editorial Policies · Open Access & Copyright · Publishing & Legal Policies