For Reviewers · Peer Review
Reviewer Guidelines & Policy NFSU
Everything a reviewer needs: what we ask, how to evaluate a manuscript, how to write and submit your report, and the ethical standards that govern Peer Review at NFSU Journal of Cyber Security and Digital Forensics.
Peer Review is the foundation of scholarly quality. Reviewers give their expertise and time to help authors improve their work and to help editors reach sound decisions. Thank you for supporting NFSU Journal of Cyber Security and Digital Forensics; these guidelines explain exactly what is expected.
[01]
The Reviewer's Role
As a reviewer you provide an independent, expert and confidential assessment of a manuscript. You advise the editor on the work's originality, validity, clarity and significance, and give authors constructive feedback. You recommend; the handling editor and Editor-in-Chief decide.
Reviews should be fair, evidence-based and courteous. Judge the manuscript on its scholarly merit — never on the authors' identity, nationality, gender, seniority or institution.
[02]
Before You Accept an Invitation
Before agreeing to review, please confirm all of the following:
Expertise
- The topic falls within your area of competence.
- You can assess the methods and analysis.
No conflict of interest
- No recent collaboration, shared funding, mentorship or rivalry with the authors.
- No financial or personal interest in the outcome.
Availability
- You can complete the review within the stated timeline.
- You can give it proper attention.
Confidentiality
- You will treat the manuscript as a privileged document.
- You will not share or delegate it without the editor's approval.
If you have a conflict, or cannot review in time, please decline promptly — and, if you can, suggest an alternative qualified reviewer. Declining is always acceptable and appreciated.
[03]
Review Timeline
| Step | Expected |
|---|---|
| Respond to the invitation | within 4 days |
| Complete and submit the review | within 4 days of accepting |
| Re-review of a revised manuscript | within 2 days |
If you need more time, tell the editorial office as early as possible so timelines to authors can be managed.
[04]
What to Evaluate
Assess the manuscript against these criteria — support each judgement with specific, actionable comments:
Originality & significance
- Is the work novel and important?
- Does it advance the field?
Methodology & rigour
- Is the design sound and reproducible?
- Are analyses and controls appropriate?
Results & interpretation
- Are conclusions supported by the data?
- Are limitations acknowledged?
Clarity & presentation
- Is the writing clear and well structured?
- Are figures, tables and references adequate?
Literature & context
- Is prior work fairly cited?
- Is the contribution properly positioned?
Ethics & integrity
- Are approvals, consent and disclosures present?
- Any signs of plagiarism or data concerns?
[05]
Writing Your Review
A helpful review is specific, balanced and constructive. Please structure it in two parts:
- 1
Comments to the authors
Open with a short summary of the study and its main claim (shows you have read it carefully). Then give major points (issues affecting validity or conclusions) followed by minor points (clarity, figures, typos). Number your points and refer to page/line numbers.
- 2
Confidential comments to the editor
Give your candid overall assessment and recommendation, and flag any ethical concerns. These comments are not shared with the authors.
Tone
Be professional and respectful. Critique the work, not the authors. Avoid dismissive or hostile language; frame problems as opportunities to improve the manuscript.
[06]
Recommendation Categories
Conclude with one recommendation. The final decision rests with the Editor-in-Chief.
| Recommendation | Meaning |
|---|---|
| Accept | Suitable for publication, subject to minor editorial checks. |
| Minor revision | Small changes needed; re-review usually not required. |
| Major revision | Substantive changes needed; manuscript returned for re-review. |
| Reject | Not suitable — with clear, constructive reasons. |
| Reject & resubmit | Fundamentally reworkable as a new submission. |
[07]
Reviewer Ethics & Conduct
Reviewers at NFSU Journal of Cyber Security and Digital Forensics follow the COPE Ethical Guidelines for Peer Reviews :
- Objectivity — assess on merit; avoid personal bias.
- Confidentiality — never share, cite or use the manuscript or its data.
- Timeliness — meet deadlines or notify the editor early.
- Disclosure — declare any conflict of interest before accepting.
- No unfair use — do not use unpublished ideas, methods or data for personal advantage.
- Constructiveness — give specific, actionable feedback.
- Integrity — do not attempt to identify the authors, or contact them directly, about the manuscript.
[08]
Confidentiality & Anonymity
The manuscript and all associated materials are strictly confidential until published. Do not discuss the manuscript with anyone or retain copies after review. Under our double-anonymous model, do not attempt to discover the authors' identity, and do not reveal your own identity within your comments.
If you wish to involve a colleague or trainee in the review (a mentored review), obtain the editor's permission first and name the co-reviewer so their contribution can be credited.
[09]
Use of AI in Peer Review
Key rule
Reviewers must not upload manuscripts, figures or any part of a submission to generative-AI tools (e.g. ChatGPT). Doing so breaches confidentiality, as the content may be retained or reused.
You may use AI to check the grammar of your own written review, but the intellectual assessment, judgement and recommendation must be entirely your own. If you use AI in any way connected with the review, disclose it to the editor.
[10]
Flagging Ethical Concerns
If, while reviewing, you suspect any of the following, raise it with the editor in your confidential comments rather than acting on it yourself:
- Plagiarism or substantial overlap with other work.
- Data fabrication, falsification or image manipulation.
- Missing ethics approval, consent, or trial registration.
- Undisclosed conflicts of interest or redundant publication.
The editor will investigate under the journal's Publication Ethics policy and the relevant COPE flowcharts.
[11]
Reviewing Revised Manuscripts
When a revised manuscript returns to you, review the authors' point-by-point response alongside the changes. Confirm whether your concerns have been addressed, keep further requests proportionate, and avoid introducing entirely new demands that could have been raised in the first round.
[12]
Recognition for Reviewers
We value reviewers' contributions and offer recognition:
- ORCID / Web of Science (Publons) — verified review records added to your profile, with your consent.
- Reviewer certificates — issued on request.
- Annual acknowledgement — reviewers thanked in the journal (names only, never linked to specific manuscripts).
[13]
Reviewer Checklist
0 of 8 completeRun through this before submitting your review (for your own use — not saved):
Contact
Questions about a review, deadlines or the process: editor@nfsu.org. To join our reviewer panel, send your CV, areas of expertise and ORCID iD to the same address.